A fresh controversy has erupted within the Indian Overseas Congress (IOC) after senior members openly criticised its chairman, Sam Pitroda, for praising Prime Minister Narendra Modi. The remarks have triggered internal disagreements, with some leaders demanding Pitroda’s immediate removal from his position.
The dispute began after Pitroda described Modi as a warm, kind, loving and caring person at a personal level. Although he maintained that his personal relationship with the Prime Minister did not affect his political differences, several Congress members expressed concern that such statements could weaken the party’s political message.
Canada-based IOC activist Devanshu Narang wrote to Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge, calling Pitroda’s comments shameful and urging the leadership to remove him as chairman. Narang claimed that many party members were shocked by the public praise.
IOC vice chairman George Abraham also raised strong objections in an email addressed to Pitroda. He argued that praising Modi’s personal qualities could create confusion among overseas Congress supporters, particularly when the organisation was attempting to highlight concerns about secularism, democracy and minority rights.
Abraham acknowledged that political opponents could maintain respectful personal relationships. However, he insisted that personal kindness and political leadership should be judged separately.
Referring to the violence in Manipur and past communal conflicts, Abraham questioned whether the Prime Minister’s personal warmth could be separated from his government's handling of sensitive national issues. He also raised concerns about religious minorities and proposed changes to regulations governing foreign-funded organisations.
The controversy follows a recent exchange between Modi and Pitroda during Diwali. Pitroda had referred to the Prime Minister as an old friend and recalled visiting his home in Gujarat. Modi subsequently addressed him as "Sam bhai" while exchanging festive greetings.
Pitroda later defended his remarks, explaining that personal respect did not mean political agreement. He maintained that it was possible to disagree with someone's ideology while preserving a cordial relationship.
Despite the criticism, Pitroda has continued accompanying Congress leader Rahul Gandhi during his ongoing visit to the United States.
This is not the first time Pitroda has faced controversy within the party. During the 2024 Lok Sabha election campaign, he stepped down as IOC chairman following controversial remarks comparing the physical appearances of Indians from different regions. He was reinstated a month later.
The latest disagreement has once again placed Pitroda under scrutiny and raised questions about how Congress leaders should approach personal relationships with political opponents.
With demands for his removal growing among some overseas members, attention has now shifted to the Congress leadership and whether it will intervene in the dispute.
Reader Comments 0