The Supreme Court on Friday dismissed Tamil Nadu's latest plea seeking the release of its pending share of Cauvery river water from Karnataka. During the hearing, the court made a sharp remark, suggesting that the state appeared to have "lots of money to waste on lawyers" after filing yet another application in the long-running inter-state water dispute.
A bench comprising Justices Vikram Nath and Aparesh Kumar Singh rejected Tamil Nadu's application, which sought directions to Karnataka to release 1.3 thousand million cubic feet (TMC) of water per day for 10 days at Billigundulu, the key water-measuring station along the Karnataka-Tamil Nadu border.
Tamil Nadu had claimed that Karnataka owed it a backlog of 11.719 TMC of Cauvery water up to October 6. The state argued that despite having sufficient water in its reservoirs, Karnataka had failed to fulfil its obligations, creating difficulties for farmers in Tamil Nadu.
During the proceedings, Justice Vikram Nath made the pointed observation after noting that Tamil Nadu had filed another application on the same day seeking fresh directions against Karnataka.
"The application is dismissed. You have filed another application today. It looks like the State of Tamil Nadu has lots of money to waste on lawyers," the judge remarked while announcing the court's decision.
The bench indicated that it was also inclined to dismiss the fresh application. However, Tamil Nadu's counsel requested an adjournment on that matter.
In its plea, Tamil Nadu maintained that Karnataka had approximately 49 TMC of combined water storage in its reservoirs, which it considered sufficient to meet the state's water-sharing obligations. It also accused the Cauvery Water Management Authority (CWMA) and the Cauvery Water Regulation Committee (CWRC) of failing to ensure the release of the outstanding water despite holding regular meetings.
Karnataka, however, opposed the application, arguing that several districts in the state were facing drought conditions. It maintained that its irrigation allocations had already been reduced and that the existing water-sharing mechanism was adequately addressing the situation.
Under the Supreme Court's water-sharing framework, Karnataka is required to release 177 TMC of Cauvery water to Tamil Nadu during a normal water year. The allocation is adjusted proportionately during years of distress or inadequate rainfall.
Tamil Nadu has repeatedly argued that the burden of reduced rainfall cannot fall entirely on the lower riparian state, particularly when its farmers are dependent on Cauvery water for irrigation.
The latest order marks another setback for Tamil Nadu in the decades-old dispute, which continues to create tensions between the two neighbouring states.
Reader Comments 0